A Fascinating Dinner with Bitternut Homestead
The housing market in Syracuse is broken, like most places. Let's talk about the thing giving me hope. Bitternut Cooperative Homestead is a great initiative by Frank Cetera to build a better model of housing in Syracuse. One that breeds community, affordable housing, and bettering the environment.

The housing market in Syracuse is broken (read the Syracuse Housing Study), like most places. The city is majority single-family land use for housing. Let's talk about the thing giving me hope. Bitternut Cooperative Homestead is a great initiative by Frank Cetera to build a better model of housing in Syracuse. One that breeds community, affordable housing, and bettering the environment.
Let's talk about hope for a better future:
Let's first define some terms:
- Co-op (Cooperative): "For practical intents and purposes, a co-op can be defined as a building that is jointly owned by a corporation made up of all its inhabitants. When you buy into a co-op, you’re not purchasing a piece of property – rather, you’re personally buying shares in a nonprofit corporation that allows you to live in the residence." (RocketMortage)
You may have interacted with one through smaller banks/credit unions. Or if you are in NYC, maybe you'll see these listed on https://streeteasy.com/. - Intentional Community: You may have heard the term commune before especially in the context of 1960s/70s. They're different, "Cohousing is a type of “intentional community,” in which people make a conscious choice to live together as a group. However, it’s not the same thing as a commune, in which a group of families jointly own a plot of land and share all their income and other resources." (MoneyCrashers) Bitternut is an intentional community that is co-op housing, it's not a commune.
What is Bitternut Homestead?
I don't think I can do this better than quoting the prospectus.
"The Bitternut Homestead is located at 717 Otisco St, in the Near Westside, near downtown Syracuse, NY; and provides products and services, including:
- Shared Home - a 1,900 sq. ft. home with access to full kitchen, pantry, dining room, sitting/tv room, wood burning cast iron stove, multi-purpose room, home office space, half-bath/half-utility room, clothes washer, enclosed side-porch bicycle parking, attic and basement storage, private bedrooms, full bath on 2nd floor with walk-in shower and cast iron clawfoot bathtub, guest room.
- Affordability - 4 Residents at current $350 a month afford a whole 3-bedroom house at $1,400, under the neighborhood average of $1,446, while offering over double the space of an average apartment of 830 Sq. Ft.
- Edible Landscaping and Kitchen Gardening - All residents contribute 2 hours weekly to garden & landscape work. The value this returns is hard to measure but consider our garlic harvest as one example. By spending 2 hours together preparing beds and planting 100 cloves, we harvested 80 bulbs this year.
"
Check out their Instagram - if you are also vegetarian or just into urban farming check it out:
Dinner:
This was the first time I had actually met Frank in real life. Somehow we were connected on LinkedIn and I'd been following Bitternut Instagram. He's a nice guy, it's very clear he's genuinely passionate about this.
Also, this was the first time I had met the other guests at the table.
Frank made a great meal from veggies from their garden, a guava paste salsa from Cuba, and a wonderful gooseberry jam from the garden with the churro waffles.
David educated me on student housing co-ops in Ann Arbor that was started in response to a lack of affordable housing. Could students do that here?
Could the residents of Syracuse do that? Well, they are and we'll get to that.
Notes:
Other student housing groups:
- Cornell
- Not fully related but Cornell has a whole website about co-ops in their general form and founding them. Very interesting stuff - http://cooperatives.dyson.cornell.edu/
- MIT
Lindsey told me about another co-op in Syracuse, Bread and Roses, (Facebook is more up-to-date). As well as Syracuse Grows, a network of community gardens in Syracuse.
There was talk about the co-op model and how the shares work. Class A vs B and the roles and responsibilities included in them. I like how the higher the investment of money you put in (Class A) you get voting rights but to retain ideological investment there is also a work requirement in it.
Also, in general, there was talk about community and foraging for wild plants in the city.
Community is a key to their success, there is something very special happening there.
After learning about co-ops my mind is racing with ideas of could I start one?
So I've now rented "Utopia Drive" by Erik Reece to learn about the current landscape of commune-ish intentional communities and "America's Communal Utopia's" edited by Donald E. Pitzer to get a historical lens on it from the library.
Want to discuss this further?
If you sign up as a member, it's free, you can comment and get these posts to your email. I do this to reduce spam.
You can also email "respond" (at) {this domain}.
.